Amazon ordered to refund Seiko watch buyer who received plastic roll
A consumer commission in Visakhapatnam, India has told Amazon and a seller to refund a shopper who found a polythene roll instead of her Seiko watch, and to pay compensation on top.

Key takeaways
- A consumer commission in Visakhapatnam ordered Amazon and a seller to refund Rs 27,000, about $289, with interest.
- The buyer paid Rs 27,000 for a Seiko SRPD61K1 listed at Rs 30,000 after a 10% discount.
- The parcel arrived on 11 May 2025 holding only a black polythene roll, and the refund never came.
- Amazon and the seller must also pay Rs 31,000, about $331, in compensation and litigation costs.
What happened
The panel also awarded compensation and costs.
The buyer had ordered a Seiko SRPD61K1, a model with a green dial on a steel bracelet, for her son.
The order and the empty box
The purchase was made on 5 May 2025. The parcel arrived a day ahead of schedule, on 11 May, but the box contained no watch at all.
She asked Amazon for a return, and the package was picked up on 13 May. The refund, however, never reached her. She later bought the same model from a Titan showroom in Visakhapatnam on 23 June 2025.
The ruling and what it means

The commission ordered Amazon and the seller to return the Rs 27,000 payment with interest. On top of the refund, both must pay a combined Rs 31,000, about $331, in compensation and litigation costs.
For shoppers, the case shows that consumer commissions can order refunds plus extra costs when a delivered package turns out to be empty or fraudulent. Buyers should keep order records and delivery evidence when a high-value parcel goes wrong.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



