Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook camera roll feature
The Garante Privacy issued its largest ever penalty after finding that a Facebook feature read Android users' photo libraries without valid consent. Meta says it will appeal.

Key takeaways
- Italy's Garante Privacy fined Meta €805 million, about $887 million, its largest penalty to date.
- A Facebook feature since 2023 suggested Android camera roll photos for posts using a single app-wide permission granted after a vague notice.
- Around 20 million Italian Android users were affected, and users who already granted the permission are still covered by the order.
- Meta must seek specific consent, keep the feature off by default, and report progress within 30 and 90 days; it says it will appeal.
In this article
What the regulator found

The penalty concerns a Facebook feature that reached the photos and videos stored on Android phones without proper permission. It is the largest fine the Italian regulator has ever issued.
The feature, which has existed since 2023, proposes pictures and clips from a phone's photo library as material for new Facebook posts. The Garante began investigating in July 2025 after a complaint from the consumer group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti in Bolzano, and then carried out its own technical analysis of the app.
Why the permission was judged invalid
The regulator concluded that the feature breached Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code, which implements the European ePrivacy Directive. Facebook requested access to the camera roll through a single permission covering the whole app. Before that request, users saw a vague notice about enabling other functions that never mentioned photo suggestions.
Under Italian rules, the smartphone counts as part of a person's private life, so any access to its contents requires free and informed consent. This applies even when no data leaves the device and no harm is shown. The Garante also noted that a full permission lets an app read the entire photo library, usually permanently, with no way for users or regulators to verify what is actually accessed.
Around 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. People who have not updated the app, or who already accepted the permission, remain within scope of the decision.
The dispute over who should decide
Meta argued that the Irish data protection authority should have handled the case instead. The Garante rejected this argument because the ePrivacy rules contain no one stop shop mechanism for such matters.
The investigation did not examine whether the photos were used to train artificial intelligence, something Meta denies.
How the size of the penalty was set
The Garante listed several factors behind the amount. It said Meta did not cooperate fully during the investigation, and pointed to the large number of affected users and an earlier decision against the company from 2019. Changes Meta made after the complaint were treated in its favour, but the regulator described them as late and limited to people who update the app.
The sum equals about 0.47 percent of Meta's global turnover. If Meta misses the deadline, the feature must stay switched off for anyone who has not given valid consent.
What Meta must now do
The order requires Meta to request a separate, specific consent for the feature and to explain clearly what it does and how to disable it. The feature must remain off by default, including for users who previously granted the broad permission. Meta must report the steps it has already started within 30 days and the completed measures within 90 days.
Meta says it will appeal. A company spokesperson described the fine as disproportionate and said the feature simply helps people share content on Facebook. According to Meta, permission is always requested and can be changed at any time in the app settings. The company has not said whether it will alter the feature in other countries.
Wider pressure on Meta
The Italian penalty adds to Meta's existing legal troubles over data handling. In October, a judge in New Mexico ordered the company to pay $25 billion after a jury found more than 43 million violations of the state's consumer protection laws.
For readers, the case is a reminder that a single broad permission on a phone can grant an app lasting access to an entire photo library. Regulators in Europe are increasingly willing to test how consent rules apply to features that read content directly from a device.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



