Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake review divides fans over Metacritic
A mixed Slant Magazine review of the Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake lowered its Metascore from 96 to 95, prompting fan criticism. The Switch 2 game remains the top-rated title of 2026 on Metacritic.

Key takeaways
- Slant Magazine gave the Switch 2 game 3.5 out of five, which Metacritic lists as 70 out of 100.
- The review lowered the Metascore from 96 to 95, according to Notebookcheck.
- The game remains Metacritic's top-rated title of 2026 and has a 9.6 user score.
- Fans accuse Slant of seeking attention, while Notebookcheck notes the magazine often posts contrarian scores.
In this article
A mixed review changes the score
According to Notebookcheck, the Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake now has a Metascore of 95. The score is on Metacritic, a site that averages critic reviews. The change followed a mixed review from Slant Magazine.
It gave the Switch 2 game 3.5 out of five. Metacritic converts that score to 70 out of 100. Before the Slant review, the game's Metascore was 96.
The Switch 2 version remains the top-rated title of 2026 on Metacritic. Notebookcheck says this is the case. It also has a user score of 9.6.
The 95 Metascore comes from critic reviews. The 9.6 is a user rating. The drop from 96 to 95 has drawn attention. The Slant entry is the only mixed score cited by Notebookcheck.
Why the Slant score stands out
Notebookcheck reports that Slant Magazine published its review late. It appeared a week after the review embargo expired. The embargo is the time when reviews can be published. The release date had also passed.
That timing made the score stand out. It stood apart from the 116 Metacritic scores already posted. Most critics had already agreed on the game's quality.
The 70 had only a small effect on the average. Some Nintendo supporters accuse Slant of posting a low score. They say it was done to attract attention.
Notebookcheck presents this as a fan accusation. It is not a confirmed fact. The report also notes a pattern. It says the magazine has a history of ratings that differ sharply from the wider critical consensus.
The review's mixed message

The Slant review asks if another release of the Nintendo 64 game was needed. It covers the Switch 2 version as well. It points to the 2011 Nintendo 3DS port. It also notes the game's later addition to the Switch Online catalogue.
The game is a modernised version of the Nintendo 64 release. Notebookcheck says the review then undercuts its own argument. It does so by praising the remake.
The writer compliments the updated graphics. The writer also notes modernised controls, a faster pace and smoother combat. The review calls the adaptation faithful to the classic. Cole Kronman also angered some Zelda loyalists.
He said the original game was only occasionally fun. Notebookcheck reports this comment. It says the comment added to the negative reaction. It also says the positive comments make the low score harder for some fans to accept.
Slant's history of contrarian scores
Notebookcheck says Slant Magazine has a reputation for ratings that go against the trend. It gave Zelda: Breath of the Wild a 60. The Metacritic average for that game is 97. It was more generous to Red Dead Redemption 2.
Even so, its 70 is far below the 97 Metascore. The report highlights a 40 score for Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice. That game was the 2019 Game of the Year.
These examples help explain the current dispute. Some readers see the Ocarina of Time remake score as part of a pattern. The examples do not prove that Slant acted to attract attention. They do show that the magazine's ratings often sit outside the main critical group.
That pattern is part of the context for the current dispute. It helps explain the reaction.
What it means for players
Notebookcheck notes that anyone can have a view. This applies even to a widely praised game. Reddit users argue that Slant is docking the Switch 2 game. They say it is because of wider industry trends.
They also say Nintendo is leaning more on remakes. They say other publishers are doing the same. This is a claim made by users. It is not a confirmed finding.
Metacritic readers can respond to ratings they dislike. They can post their own scores. Notebookcheck says the Switch 2 version has survived review bombing. Review bombing is when users post many negative ratings.
The game still has the highest user rating on the site. That score is 9.6. For readers, the episode shows how one late review can change a public score.
It can do so even when most critics agree. It also shows how review timing and fan reaction can shape discussion around a major release.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



