Zelda: Ocarina of Time Metacritic rating falls after GTA 6 bombing
The user score for the Switch 2 remake fell from 9.6 to 8.7 after a wave of zero ratings, according to Notebookcheck. The drop followed a similar flood of negative scores aimed at GTA 6.

Key takeaways
- Notebookcheck reports the Zelda: Ocarina of Time user score fell from 9.6 to 8.7.
- The drop followed a wave of zero ratings after GTA 6 received many negative user scores.
- Metacritic user ratings require only an email address, according to the report.
- A Reddit analysis of 14,000 ratings linked many negative GTA 6 reviews to Zelda ratings.
In this article
What happened
According to Notebookcheck, the user rating for Zelda: Ocarina of Time on Metacritic fell from 9.6 to 8.7. The drop followed a wave of zero scores, a practice known as review bombing. It happened less than 24 hours after a similar flood of negative ratings hit GTA 6, another popular 2026 release. Notebookcheck describes the event as a counter-review bombing. The figures come from Notebookcheck and have not been independently verified.
The Switch 2 game had held a stable user score after Metacritic opened community ratings on 6 November 2026. Notebookcheck says the new negative submissions arrived in a concentrated burst. The report says the shift required a concerted effort. The remake already had at least 20,000 user ratings. That meant a large number of low scores was needed to move the average.
GTA 6 backlash spreads

GTA 6 has a Metascore of 99 from critics, according to Notebookcheck. Metascore is the critic average. The report says that score ties the original N64 Zelda classic for the best critic average mentioned. The user score for GTA 6 is much lower, at 5.6 out of 10. The report says the GTA 6 user score is far below the critic average.
Some Rockstar supporters appear to be looking for a scapegoat after the low user score. Notebookcheck says text attached to zero ratings often insults developers or players who enjoy the story of Lucia and Jason. The complaints do not usually focus on gameplay. Some new submissions on the Ocarina of Time page also compare the game with GTA 6, despite few similarities.
Why user scores can move fast
Metacritic user ratings require only an email address, according to Notebookcheck. Users do not have to prove that they own a game. No purchase proof is required. That makes organised campaigns easier than on platforms such as Steam or the PlayStation Store. The report says this makes it easier to organise a campaign against a target.
Many observers see the back-and-forth as a flaw in the user-rating system. Notebookcheck reports that the exchange is viewed by many as a sign of a system weakness. The episode shows how quickly a community score can change when a large group acts together. The GTA 6 page shows a sharp split between critics and users.
Data from a Reddit analysis
A Reddit user named gtrhawk analysed 14,000 ratings, according to Notebookcheck. The poster reported that 83.8% of people who left negative GTA 6 reviews had not rated the modernised Zelda game. By comparison, just 33.5% of the negative Ocarina of Time reviews came from people who had not also scored GTA 6.
The analysis suggests GTA 6 advocates may be shaping views of both Game of the Year contenders. Notebookcheck presents this as a statistical insight from a Reddit post, not as a verified measurement. The figures come from a community post, not Metacritic. The post is not an official Metacritic analysis. It still fits the pattern described in the report.
What it means for players
The dispute involves two high-profile games, but the effect is on public perception. A user score can fall quickly when a motivated group submits many low ratings. That can make it harder for players to judge a game from community scores alone.
For now, the Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake remains a Game of the Year candidate in the report. The report says the two games are rival Game of the Year candidates. GTA 6 has a near-universal critic score and a very different user score. The Zelda remake already had a large user sample. The case shows a game can have strong critic scores and a weak user score. The episode is likely to keep attention on how review bombing can affect both games.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



