AirPods Max trade-offs: price, weight and repair costs
Engadget says Apple's $549 headphones sound good and work well with iPhone, but weight, case design, condensation and repair costs limit their appeal.

Key takeaways
- Engadget says the $549 AirPods Max sound good and work well with iPhone features.
- The headphones weigh 386 grams and use a Smart Case that offers limited protection.
- Apple charges $79 for battery service and about $300 for replacement after other hardware failures.
- The AirPods Max lack Bluetooth codecs for high-resolution audio and need USB-C for lossless sound.
In this article
AirPods Max trade-offs
Apple's AirPods Max remain a premium headphone option, but Engadget says the $549 price comes with several compromises. In an article published on 21 November 2026, the site looks at what buyers gain and what they give up.
The headphones recently received an update with improved active noise cancellation, or ANC, and Apple's H2 chip. Engadget says they pair especially well with iPhone through features such as Adaptive Audio, Conversation Awareness and Live Translation. Sound quality is also described as very good. The article adds that the model has not changed much since 2020, which makes the price harder to justify.
Weight and case problems

The AirPods Max are heavy for over-ear headphones. Engadget reports that the aluminium and steel build brings the weight to 386 grams, or 13.6 ounces. By comparison, the mostly plastic Beats 360 weigh 294 grams, or 10.4 ounces, and feel lighter during long listening sessions. The extra bulk can become noticeable on long flights.
The design also creates practical issues. There is no power button, so the headphones rely on the Smart Case to enter sleep mode through magnets. Engadget says the case does not protect the headphones well.
The headband remains exposed. The ear cups are not fully covered. The headphones also do not fold. Only the ear cups rotate flat, so the AirPods Max take up more space in a bag.
Engadget also points to complaints about the headband peeling over time. The AirPods Max 2 use the same design as the first generation. The article says it is unlikely that this issue has changed. Third-party cases can add the magnets needed for sleep mode, but buyers must pay extra beyond the $549 price.
Condensation and repair limits
Another concern is moisture inside the ear cups. Engadget notes that a 2025 lawsuit claimed condensation could affect sound quality and cause ear detection to fail over time. A judge later dismissed the case.
The article says the issue remains relevant for the AirPods Max 2. iFixit found no visible changes to the internal seals. Apple says moisture is easy to spot and clean because the ear cups can be removed.
Repairs are also limited. Engadget says taking the headphones apart requires special tools and removing many adhesive strips. Apple charges $79 for a battery replacement, which is the only repair the company offers.
If another hardware part fails, Apple typically replaces the headphones for about $300. At that price, buyers could buy a new pair of headphones, such as the Beats 360. Ear pads are easier to replace. They snap on and off, and Apple charges $69 for a pair, although third-party options may cost less.
Audio quality and value
Engadget says the AirPods Max sound very good, and their integration with Apple devices is a major strength. For iPhone users, features such as Adaptive Audio and Conversation Awareness make them convenient. The headphones also support Live Translation, which adds another use case for travellers and multilingual users.
For audiophiles, or listeners who want the highest sound quality, the headphones fall short in one area. Engadget says they lack Bluetooth codecs for high-resolution sound. Codecs are the compression methods used for wireless audio.
A USB-C cable is needed for lossless audio. Many rival premium headphones support formats such as LDAC and aptX HD for higher-quality wireless listening.
The article concludes that the AirPods Max are a good product, but not exceptional at $549. Buyers who value Apple ecosystem features and strong sound may still find them appealing. Those who want lighter headphones, better protection, easier repairs or high-resolution Bluetooth audio may prefer to look at alternatives. Engadget presents the headphones as a strong but flawed choice, not a clear default for every buyer.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



