Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

GadgetsLaptops & PCs

VPN vs encrypted DNS: privacy, speed and cost trade-offs

Engadget has compared VPNs with encrypted DNS, explaining that a VPN hides more of a user's activity but can cost more and slow connections, while encrypted DNS is a lighter option for hiding domain lookups.

Illustration of a laptop showing a VPN and encrypted DNS privacy comparison

Key takeaways

  • Encrypted DNS encrypts domain lookups and is often free or built into browsers, according to Engadget.
  • A VPN hides the user's IP address and encrypts all traffic, but it can reduce connection speed.
  • VPN providers can still see browsing activity, so trust in the operator matters.
  • The two tools can be used together, and encrypted DNS has few obvious costs for everyday browsing.
In this article
  1. What Engadget compared
  2. What encrypted DNS protects
  3. Where a VPN goes further
  4. Speed, cost and trust trade-offs
  5. Who should choose which

What Engadget compared

Engadget has published a guide to the VPN vs encrypted DNS choice, setting out how two common privacy tools differ in what they hide and what they cost. The article explains that both can reduce exposure online, but they work at different levels. A VPN creates an encrypted tunnel for a device's internet traffic and changes the IP address that websites see. Encrypted DNS protects the lookup step that turns a web address into an IP address.

DNS is the system that translates a web address into an IP address, the numeric label used to reach a server. By default, those requests can be visible to an internet service provider or anyone able to observe the connection, according to Engadget. The guide frames the decision as a trade-off between breadth of protection and factors such as speed, expense and trust.

What encrypted DNS protects

Encrypted DNS encrypts the domain-name lookups a browser sends to a DNS resolver. Engadget says this stops an ISP or another observer from reading which sites a user is trying to reach. It can also make it harder for an attacker to intercept a lookup and redirect a user to a different site, though the guide notes that such attacks are not made impossible. Encrypted DNS does not hide the user's IP address or encrypt other traffic, so its protection is narrower than a VPN's.

The benefits come with little obvious cost. Several encrypted DNS services are free, some browsers include a secure DNS or DNS over HTTPS setting, and the effect on connection speed is usually small because encryption applies to lookups rather than all traffic. Engadget advises users to check whether their browser already offers the setting and to follow the browser maker's guidance.

Where a VPN goes further

Illustration: server, security, internet, padlock and the labels DNS Over Https, Encrypted DNS, Engadget

A VPN encrypts all traffic between a device and the internet and routes it through a VPN server, so websites see the server's IP address rather than the user's. Engadget says this can keep an ISP from seeing which sites are visited, what is downloaded and other online activity, provided the VPN server itself is secure. The changed IP address can also let users reach streaming content that is restricted in their country, and a VPN can add protection on public Wi-Fi, where traffic is easier to intercept.

The guide says a VPN is usually the stronger option for users worried about an ISP or others seeing private information. The trade-off is that the VPN operator becomes a party that can see the user's browsing, so choosing a reputable provider matters. A VPN may also be more than many everyday browsing sessions need.

Speed, cost and trust trade-offs

Engadget notes that a VPN can slow a connection significantly because traffic takes a detour through another server. Encrypted DNS has a much smaller effect, since it only adds work when a lookup is made and many services are free. A good VPN generally offers broader protection than encrypted DNS, according to the guide, but that extra coverage may be unnecessary for ordinary browsing at home.

The guide also warns that a VPN's operator can still see the sites a user visits, so the service's trustworthiness is central to the privacy claim. The cost of a VPN is therefore not only financial. Users are relying on the provider to handle their traffic responsibly, while encrypted DNS shifts trust to the DNS resolver and the browser or operating system that manages the setting.

Who should choose which

Engadget's comparison suggests encrypted DNS is a sensible default for people who want to hide domain lookups with little effort or expense. A VPN is more useful when a user needs to hide an IP address, protect sensitive activity or use an untrusted network such as public Wi-Fi. The two can be used together, and the guide presents them as complementary rather than mutually exclusive.

For everyday browsing, encrypted DNS may be enough, while a VPN adds another layer for sessions that need more cover. Readers should check their browser or VPN provider's official documentation before changing settings, and should treat any privacy tool as one layer rather than a complete guarantee.

Sources

  1. The pros and cons of using a VPN over encrypted DNSEngadget

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.