Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

SoftwareCloud & Services

FCC orders California to stop enforcing AT&T phone service rules

The order supports AT&T's plan to replace copper lines with wireless home phone service, but California says basic service protections must still be met.

Illustration of AT&T phone lines and an FCC order about California service rules

Key takeaways

  • The FCC order preempts California rules that apply to AT&T phone service.
  • AT&T plans to cut service for 184,000 residential customers and 15,000 business customers from 1 June 2027.
  • California says wireless replacements must meet basic service standards, including Lifeline and relay services.
  • The dispute follows a March FCC order and a failed court challenge by AT&T.
In this article
  1. FCC order targets California rules
  2. Copper lines and wireless replacement
  3. California consumer protections
  4. Court fights and wider telecom dispute
  5. Who is affected and what next

FCC order targets California rules

The FCC has ordered California to stop enforcing state rules that govern AT&T phone service, according to Ars Technica. The order, released on 20 November 2026, grants AT&T's request to preempt the state rules. Preemption means federal rules can override conflicting state rules.

It follows an earlier FCC approval of AT&T's petition to discontinue service. AT&T seeks to end basic phone service for new customers. It also plans to cut service for 184,000 residential customers. The same step would affect 15,000 business customers from 1 June 2027.

FCC Chairman Brendan Carr said California's framework may have suited an earlier time. He said the framework was created 30 years ago. He said the rules no longer fit current conditions.

Copper lines and wireless replacement

AT&T is a Carrier of Last Resort in California. This means it must offer phone service to any possible customer in its territory. The dispute centres on what happens when the company moves away from its old copper network.

A closure of the old copper lines could leave many homes and businesses without modern fibre networks. AT&T says a wireless home phone product using the cellular network will be adequate. The FCC agreed. The FCC has also granted AT&T applications to swap legacy voice service for a modern alternative in certain areas.

California says wireless replacements are allowed if they meet state standards for basic service. It says AT&T must prove that its wireless service meets its Carrier of Last Resort duties. The FCC said California's rules are stopping AT&T from carrying out a federally approved transition.

California consumer protections

California's requirements include flat-rate choices for unlimited calling. They also include lower Lifeline rates. These are for eligible low-income customers. They include relay services for deaf and hard-of-hearing people.

Gomez said the CPUC process is the proper venue for deciding how modern basic service should be defined. Gomez said AT&T does not intend to end service before 1 June 2027. That gives the CPUC time to complete its work. Gomez also said the order directs the CPUC to write new protections in light of a federal ruling it opposed.

Court fights and wider telecom dispute

Illustration: law, AT&T logo, phone, mobile network and the labels California, Cpuc, FCC

AT&T had already tried to obtain the same outcome in court. A federal court turned down AT&T's request to override California's rules in July.

In March, the FCC issued an order that simplified the discontinuation of copper networks by carriers. It said state rules can be overridden when they clash with FCC discontinuance authorizations and authority. AT&T relied on that order in its legal challenge against California.

Trump officials and telecom companies have tried for years to block California's rules. The first Trump administration failed in 2019 when it tried to preempt state net neutrality laws nationwide. California later defeated internet service providers in a lawsuit over its net neutrality law.

California's net neutrality law and other telecom regulations face renewed pressure from grant rules applied by the Trump administration. This month, California refused US demands to halt enforcement of its laws. California may have to choose between enforcing its telecom laws and accepting $1.42 billion for broadband deployment to 270,571 locations.

Who is affected and what next

The dispute affects AT&T customers in California who receive service over old copper lines. It also affects new customers who might otherwise be offered basic phone service. AT&T says it does not plan to end service before 1 June 2027.

California says its consumer protections should still apply to any replacement service. The state says AT&T must show that wireless service meets its duties. Gomez said the CPUC can finish its work before the planned end date.

The case is part of a wider dispute over federal and state authority in telecom regulation. It also involves federal broadband funding for California.

Sources

  1. FCC orders California to stop enforcing phone service rules against AT&TArs Technica

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.