Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

SoftwareCloud & Services

NASA explains why Artemis III tests Blue Moon more than Starship

NASA's Human Landing System manager says the low-Earth orbit Artemis III mission is designed to keep SpaceX focused on orbital refuelling while Blue Origin proves its crew cabin. The first crewed lunar landing now falls to Artemis IV before the end of 2028.

Illustration of NASA's Artemis programme showing a lunar lander docking with an Orion spacecraft above Earth

Key takeaways

  • Artemis III is now a low-Earth orbit test mission, pushing the first crewed lunar landing to Artemis IV before the end of 2028.
  • The crew will test Blue Moon's life support systems for two days but will not enter Starship, which is limited to a two-hour docking test.
  • NASA says the split keeps SpaceX focused on orbital refuelling, a demonstration delayed by about two years since late 2024.
  • The revised architecture drops a 90-day loiter in lunar orbit and shortens initial surface stays from six and a half days to four.
In this article
  1. What changed in the Artemis plan
  2. Two landers, two very different tests
  3. Why the testing is uneven
  4. Refuelling remains the critical hurdle
  5. New tests and a simpler architecture

What changed in the Artemis plan

Illustration: rocket, NASA logo, plane, SpaceX logo and the labels Artemis Iii, Blue Origin, NASA

NASA reworked its Artemis III flight plan earlier this year, turning what was meant to be a lunar mission into a test flight in low-Earth orbit. According to Ars Technica, this means the programme's first crewed landing on the Moon now moves to Artemis IV, which NASA targets for launch before the end of 2028.

The revised mission will send a crew of four towards low-Earth orbit on NASA's Space Launch System rocket with an Orion capsule. Once in orbit, the astronauts will visit two different lunar landers under development for the agency.

Two landers, two very different tests

Orion will first dock with Blue Origin's Blue Moon lander, launched on a New Glenn rocket, for two days of checks. The crew will open the hatches, enter the pressurised cabin and test the environmental control and life support systems. Blue Origin has flown suborbital tourism flights before, but Artemis III will be its first time carrying a crew cabin in orbit, so these systems are a key focus.

After leaving Blue Moon, Orion will rendezvous with SpaceX's Starship in a slightly lower orbit, positioned below most of the Starlink satellite constellation. This docking will last only about two hours, and the astronauts will not enter Starship. The Starship vehicle will carry a full set of Raptor engines and a docking port on its nose, while the Blue Moon test article will have no main engines at all, only smaller thrusters for pointing and minor manoeuvres.

Why the testing is uneven

Steve Creech, who manages NASA's Human Landing System programme, told Ars Technica the imbalance is deliberate. Keeping SpaceX focused on orbital refuelling, the long-delayed demonstration of transferring propellant between spacecraft in orbit, matters more than testing its cabin in orbit. SpaceX already has extensive experience with life support from its Dragon crew spacecraft, while Blue Origin has comparatively little.

Creech said that adding a crew cabin test to Starship would slow down the work that really matters for SpaceX. For Blue Moon, the priority is the opposite: proving the cabin and its life support systems, with Orion handling control of the docked stack to reduce risk. On the Starship side, the lander itself will control the attitude of the combined stack during docking, which NASA expects to be a significant learning exercise given the vehicle's size.

Refuelling remains the critical hurdle

SpaceX's recovery of a Starship booster last weekend removed a major obstacle, according to Ars Technica. The catch at the launch tower should help engineers reuse rockets quickly, raising the launch rate and speeding up development of the deep space version of Starship that will carry astronauts to the lunar surface.

The refuelling demonstration has slipped by roughly two years since late 2024 as SpaceX worked through technical problems. Early next year the company plans to open a second launch site at Kennedy Space Center in Florida, alongside a second factory there, adding capacity alongside its existing site at Starbase in Texas. After Artemis III, an uncrewed Starship landing on the Moon is planned, a mission that will require large amounts of refuelling.

New tests and a simpler architecture

NASA has added requirements for both companies. SpaceX must build a prototype crew compartment, called Cabin One, at Starbase for ground testing of parts of its cabin. Blue Origin, whose first Blue Moon test flight was delayed by a rocket explosion on its launch pad in May, must hotfire a three-engine version of its lander in a vacuum chamber at NASA's facility in Ohio. The Mark 1 test vehicle flying early next year has one hydrogen-fuelled BE-7 engine; future crewed landers will have three.

Engineers also simplified the mission architecture. The earlier plan required Orion to wait in lunar orbit for up to 90 days, which Creech said drove a lot of complexity and made the landers harder to build. Under the new concept, Orion meets the landers in Earth orbit and travels to the Moon with them. Initial surface stays are now set at four days instead of six and a half.

Sources

  1. NASA’s new Moon plan is taking shape, but some big questions remainArs Technica

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.