Binding of Isaac studio pulls AI music from Repentance Plus
Nicalis removed Suno-generated tracks from a GTA-themed section of The Binding of Isaac: Repentance Plus after players found the files, as Steam reviews turned overwhelmingly negative.

Key takeaways
- AI-generated tracks were found in a Grand Theft Auto-themed section of Repentance Plus.
- Audio file metadata pointed to Suno, a generative music service.
- Nicalis said the files were removed in an update within hours of the discovery.
- Steam reviews remain overwhelmingly negative despite the fix.
In this article
What happened

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance Plus has had AI-generated music removed from one of its sections, according to The Verge. The change came after players found the tracks and the game's Steam reviews turned sharply negative over several days.
A Reddit user named ShweetsStuff spotted the songs in a part of the game that parodies Grand Theft Auto. Several audio files carried Suno metadata, which linked them back to tracks on the Suno site. Suno is a service that generates music from text prompts.
The studio's response
Edmund McMillen, the creator of The Binding of Isaac, posted on X to apologise. He said he was unaware that the Grand Theft Auto-style segment contained music made with generative AI.
Within hours of the discovery, Nicalis, the studio behind Repentance Plus, said on X that the game had been updated and the generated audio files were gone. The Verge reports that the Steam rating has not recovered and remains overwhelmingly negative.
Why disclosure rules matter
Valve asks developers to state how and when they use generative AI during development. According to The Verge, Nicalis did not appear to mention the AI music anywhere in its disclosures.
The episode shows how quickly players can trace generated assets. Metadata inside audio files gave the community a direct route from the game to the Suno catalogue.
Mixed reaction from players
Reaction on X has been more forgiving than on Steam, The Verge notes. Some users appear willing to accept McMillen's explanation, partly because he has criticised AI in game development before.
In a 2024 TikTok, he described AI-generated work as uninspired and bland. That public stance is likely why many players are giving him the benefit of the doubt while the Steam score stays low.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



