Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

SoftwareCloud & Services

Gartner says many sovereign cloud promises are marketing, not autonomy

Analysts told the Gartner IT Symposium/Xpo in Barcelona that vendors often overstate sovereignty claims, leaving European organisations exposed to foreign laws and sudden service cut-offs.

Illustration of European data centres and cloud servers beside a flag, showing sovereignty concerns

Key takeaways

  • Gartner analysts warned at the IT Symposium/Xpo in Barcelona that many sovereign cloud claims are marketing rather than genuine autonomy.
  • Gartner predicts more than 90% of EU organisations will have a sovereignty strategy by 2029.
  • A Microsoft representative told the French Senate the company could not guarantee French data would be immune to US subpoenas under the CLOUD Act.
  • Over 99% of advanced computing hardware is made outside Europe, leaving a semiconductor gap behind software sovereignty efforts.
In this article
  1. Sovereignty claims often fall short
  2. Why trust in foreign vendors has eroded
  3. Three warning signs of sovereignty washing
  4. Costs, hardware and what leaders should do

Sovereignty claims often fall short

Gartner analysts have warned that many vendors who advertise sovereign technology are engaging in what they call sovereignty washing: marketing that promises autonomy while hiding structural reasons why it cannot be delivered. The warning came from analysts René Buest and Bettina Tratz-Ryan at the Gartner IT Symposium/Xpo in Barcelona, according to EE Times.

Buest said sovereignty is moving from a question of where data sits to a matter of economic and operational survival. Dependencies that once made businesses more efficient, he argued, must now be treated as possible continuity risks.

Gartner's research underpins the urgency. The firm expects digital sovereignty to become a central part of national security planning worldwide by 2030, and predicts that more than 90% of organisations in the European Union will have a sovereignty strategy by 2029.

Why trust in foreign vendors has eroded

A decade ago, most companies moved workloads into large public clouds run by US providers, drawn by scale, advanced services and lower management costs. Buest said that consensus has broken down amid geopolitical instability and legal disputes. Ten years ago, he noted, there was more trust among nations and in vendors.

Two fears now dominate boardroom discussions: unauthorised outside access to data, and losing access to critical technology altogether. The legal exposure became concrete during testimony in the French Senate, where a Microsoft representative acknowledged the company could not promise that French records would be shielded from US subpoenas under the CLOUD Act, a US law governing access to data held abroad.

Buest also cited examples of sudden cut-offs, sometimes described as a kill switch.

Three warning signs of sovereignty washing

Illustration: warning, cloud, law, building and the labels Cloud Act, Gartner, RISC-V

Buest listed three red flags for buyers. The first is compliance theatre, where encryption and regulatory checklists are presented as proof of sovereignty, even though technical safeguards cannot protect an organisation if systems are switched off remotely.

The second is non-binding pledges and data boundary promises that give way when a vendor's home country passes laws demanding access. The third is ownership: foreign vendors build local data centres but keep control of the core software and intellectual property.

Gartner separates digital sovereignty into three tiers. Data sovereignty, meaning where information is stored, is the weakest level on its Sovereign Cloud Deployment Spectrum. Operational sovereignty requires infrastructure run independently by domestic organisations. Technological sovereignty, Buest said, is effectively out of reach for most European organisations today.

Costs, hardware and what leaders should do

Tratz-Ryan described a trilemma facing organisations: performance, cost ceilings and autonomy. Mandates such as the EU's Digital Operational Resilience Act require financial firms to guarantee continuity and assess single points of vendor failure. Yet because domestic alternatives remain small, achieving sovereignty often means duplicating entire technology stacks, which drives up spending.

She advised leaders to pursue strategic optionality: identify which dependencies create unacceptable risk, where resilience is enough, and where managed interdependence remains the practical choice.

Hardware is a further chokepoint. Buest told EE Times that more than 99% of advanced computing hardware comes from outside Europe, with chip designs dominated by US firms such as Intel, AMD and Nvidia. Arm, the UK-based chip design company, is majority-owned by Japan's SoftBank and led from America. European projects such as DARE are exploring RISC-V, an open chip architecture, and China has built up its own semiconductor capacity partly in response to US export controls.

To reduce exposure to a sudden cut-off, Buest pointed to a model called SovereignOps, which separates running a service from owning its intellectual property. Local providers operate the service under a conditional licence, lowering the risk of losing access overnight. The broader message for buyers is to scrutinise vendor claims closely and decide where true autonomy is necessary and where dependence can be managed.

Sources

  1. Gartner Warns of Risks Behind Sovereign Tech ClaimsEE Times

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.