Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

SoftwareCloud & Services

NASA's new Artemis plan puts extra strain on Orion spacecraft

Changes meant to ease Moon landings for SpaceX and Blue Origin force Orion to fly in ways it was never designed for, from reversed thrust to longer stays near Earth.

Illustration of the Orion spacecraft docked with a lunar lander on its way to the Moon

Key takeaways

  • NASA's revised Artemis plan has Starship docking with Orion in high-Earth orbit and Blue Moon meeting it in low-lunar orbit.
  • Orion must fly to the Moon in a reversed configuration, requiring ESA and Airbus to modify its Service Module propellant tanks.
  • Artemis III is now a 2027 low-Earth orbit docking demonstration, raising thermal and space debris concerns for Orion.
  • Lockheed is working three shifts to hold a zero-margin schedule for a summer or autumn 2027 launch.
In this article
  1. A new flight plan for Artemis
  2. Flying in reverse towards the Moon
  3. New hazards in low-Earth orbit
  4. A compressed schedule for docking work
  5. Why it matters

A new flight plan for Artemis

NASA has reworked parts of its Artemis Moon programme to give its two lander providers more flexibility, according to Ars Technica. SpaceX will fuel its Starship lunar lander in low-Earth orbit before it docks with Orion in high-Earth orbit, and the two vehicles will then travel to the Moon together. Blue Origin's Blue Moon lander, meanwhile, will now meet Orion in low-lunar orbit.

These changes help the landers, but they add work for Orion, the crew capsule built by Lockheed Martin. Ars Technica spoke to Kirk Shireman, Orion programme manager at Lockheed, about what the new mission profiles mean for the spacecraft.

Flying in reverse towards the Moon

Because of how Starship docks, Orion has to travel to the Moon with its European-built Service Module at the front of the stack, pushing the spacecraft in a direction it was never designed for. Shireman said this reversed posture creates problems for the propulsion system.

The issue lies in the propellant tanks. In normal flight, liquid fuel settles at the end of the tank where the engines draw it in. When thrust comes from the opposite direction, the liquid moves towards the gas side instead, which Shireman warned can cause serious problems. The European Space Agency and its contractor Airbus are therefore modifying the tanks for Starship missions.

Acceleration is another concern. During the original translunar injection burn, Orion would feel about 0.1 to 0.15 g. With Starship providing the thrust, that rises to roughly 0.8 to 1 g, acting the opposite way. The spacecraft's structure must now be certified for this much stronger force.

New hazards in low-Earth orbit

Illustration: rocket, environment, NASA logo, SpaceX logo and the labels Artemis Iii, Blue Origin, NASA

Earlier this year, NASA removed the lunar landing from Artemis III and turned the mission into a test of rendezvous and docking in low-Earth orbit, now targeted for 2027. Orion was only built for short stays near Earth, so this creates fresh challenges.

Heat is one of them. Orion was designed for the colder environment of deep space, and features such as a silver exterior tape that limits heat loss must be partly removed for this mission. Engineers are also studying how to manage electrical loads to protect the avionics and the crew cabin.

Space debris is a further risk. Shireman said the debris environment near Earth is far more crowded than in deep space, and the risk assessment is not finished. It should be complete by January, and if the risk proves too high, Orion's orbit for the mission could be changed.

A compressed schedule for docking work

Docking with Starship and Blue Moon involves more than simple mechanics. Engineers must account for hooks, connectors and pins, thruster exhaust that could damage the landers, and the possibility that Orion's laser docking sensor misreads reflections from the landers' surfaces.

Shireman said this work was always planned, but was meant to be spread over time and not done for both landers at once. The new schedule crams it all into a short window before a launch in summer or autumn of 2027.

Lockheed is running three shifts to keep up. Shireman described the schedule as having zero margin, with the team fighting daily to save even half a shift.

Why it matters

Shireman said he supports the urgency that NASA, under administrator Isaacman, brings to the race with China to return humans to the Moon. But he cautioned that speed must not come at the cost of safety, noting his own experience at NASA during the Challenger and Columbia accidents.

His message, as reported by Ars Technica, is that the agency has a duty not to move so quickly that it takes undue risks. The coming months of tank modifications, thermal analysis and debris assessment will show whether Orion can absorb the burden the new plan places on it.

Sources

  1. To make Moon landings easier, NASA is making life harder for OrionArs Technica

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.