Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

GadgetsSmart Home

San Diego ends Flock camera and smart streetlight contracts

The city council voted to cancel deals with Flock and Ubicquia, turning off more than 500 cameras three years after the programme was approved.

Illustration of a city streetlight with a camera attached above a road in San Diego

Key takeaways

  • San Diego's city council voted to cancel contracts with Flock and Ubicquia.
  • More than 500 licence plate readers and smart streetlights will stop operating.
  • Police said vehicle theft fell 20 percent since 2023 and 689 stolen vehicles were recovered.
  • Flock, valued at an estimated $8.3 billion, said it accepts but disagrees with the decision.
In this article
  1. What the council decided
  2. A reversal after three years
  3. Police figures and the company's response
  4. Why the vote matters

What the council decided

San Diego's city council voted on Monday evening to end its contracts with two surveillance vendors, Flock and Ubicquia, according to Ars Technica. The move switches off more than 500 cameras that were installed across the city.

The decision covers Flock's automatic licence plate readers (ALPR), which use software to read number plates, and Ubicquia's smart streetlights, which housed cameras and sensors. The two systems worked together.

Mayor Todd Gloria said in a social media post that he accepted the council's choice and would let the cancellation stand rather than block it.

A reversal after three years

Illustration: security, camera, privacy, price and the labels Flock, San Diego, Surveillance

The vote marks a sharp change from 2023, when the mayor and other city leaders pressed the council to approve the programme. At the time, the City of San Diego Privacy Advisory Board urged the council to reject the plan.

One board member, Pegah Parsi, wrote on LinkedIn that she felt vindicated and called on institutions to listen to their expert advisers. The advocacy group Secure Justice, based in Oakland, said it has recorded at least 513 Flock contracts ending across states run by both parties.

This is the second time in under a decade that San Diego has tried and then dropped smart streetlights. The city bought thousands of units from GE Current, a previous administration shut them down in 2020, and Ubicquia later acquired the platform and proposed a new installation with Flock.

Police figures and the company's response

At Monday's meeting, police representatives said vehicle theft had fallen by 20 percent since 2023. They credited the Flock cameras with helping to recover 689 stolen vehicles.

Flock spokesperson Andrew Smith told Ars Technica that the company accepts the city's decision but disagrees with it. He argued that removing a tool used to solve violent crimes slows cases, makes organised retail theft easier and delays justice for victims.

Flock is one of the largest cities to end its relationship with the startup, which has an estimated valuation of $8.3 billion. Council member Stephen Whitburn withdrew his support in October, saying residents should feel safe and that cameras causing many San Diegans to feel unsafe had lost their value as a public safety tool.

Why the vote matters

The campaign against the cameras was led by the Transparent and Responsible Use of Surveillance Technology (TRUST) SD Coalition. Its member Lily Irani told Ars Technica that broad coalitions across the political spectrum drove the result.

The case shows how local scrutiny of police technology can reverse a programme even after it is running. It also puts pressure on other cities weighing similar contracts, with advocacy groups tracking cancellations nationwide.

Residents who want to follow the change can check city notices for when the devices stop operating. Ars Technica reports that the cameras will go dark following the vote.

Sources

  1. San Diego dumps both Flock cameras and smart streetlightsArs Technica

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.