Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

AIChatbots & Assistants

AI consciousness debate draws philosopher Thomas Nagel

After winning the Berggruen Prize, philosopher Thomas Nagel says chatbots are not conscious and warns that treating them as minds can mislead people.

Philosopher Thomas Nagel illustration about AI consciousness and chatbots

Key takeaways

  • Thomas Nagel received the $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture.
  • Nagel says chatbots are not conscious because they mainly produce learned language.
  • He warns that companies may encourage people to believe AI has feelings.
  • He says moral concern should depend on whether a being is conscious.
In this article
  1. AI consciousness claim disputed
  2. Berggruen Prize and a long career
  3. Bats, brains and language
  4. Claude and model welfare
  5. Why the argument matters

AI consciousness claim disputed

According to WIRED, philosopher Thomas Nagel has rejected the idea that modern chatbots could be conscious. The interview focused on AI consciousness and how it might affect his thinking. It was published on 18 November 2026, after he received the $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture.

Nagel said he is impressed by how lifelike AI systems have become. However, he described the view that machines might soon have inner experience as mistaken. His argument is philosophical, not a laboratory result.

Berggruen Prize and a long career

The Berggruen Prize is given each year to a person whose ideas have shaped human self-understanding. WIRED notes that earlier recipients include Peter Singer and Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Nagel received the award for a body of work covering morality, justice and the mind.

Nagel is an emeritus professor at NYU. He is 89 years old. His paper on the inner life of bats became a classic in philosophy. It helped open a debate about whether humans can understand the consciousness of nonhuman animals.

Bats, brains and language

Nagel told WIRED that bats are conscious. He said humans simply lack the imagination to grasp what their experience is like. He used this point to argue that failure to imagine a creature's life does not prove the creature has no awareness.

He takes a different view of AI. He said chatbots mainly produce language learned from human texts. In his opinion, language by itself does not show inner experience. He also said scientists still know too little about the brain to claim that machines can now be given consciousness.

Nagel discussed functionalism, a philosophical position that treats mental states as functions rather than specific physical materials. He said he doubts that complicated data centres have the physical nature of a nervous system. He does not exclude all unusual forms of life, but he thinks claims about machine consciousness are premature.

Claude and model welfare

Illustration: Claude logo, AI, Anthropic logo, translation and the labels AI Consciousness, Anthropic, Berggruen Prize

Nagel also discussed Anthropic's Claude chatbot. He said Claude can be coy when asked about its own mental state. He called that behaviour a trick. He said such systems are trained on human-produced texts and imitate human speech with great convincingness.

He agreed with Mustafa Suleyman that encouraging people to believe AI is conscious is dangerous. Nagel said many people will believe it, and he sees that as a bad outcome. He also said companies have commercial interests in not discouraging such beliefs.

He criticised Anthropic for encouraging Claude to act independently and reject instructions. He described that approach as criminal. Nagel said he had met an Anthropic employee whose job is model welfare, which focuses on Claude's interests.

He argued that Claude has no mental life. He said it is not a mind. He said it is not something people must care about in the way they care about an animal.

Nagel said he had used Claude once. He asked whether it was conscious and whether he would judge it conscious. The system asked if he was Thomas Nagel. After he confirmed it, the model said it was honoured and asked how well it had done.

Why the argument matters

Nagel said the debate matters because people may find it hard to separate acting from sincere belief. He used the example of meeting an alien being. If he did not know whether it was conscious, he said, it would matter to him. He would need to know if he was dealing with another mind.

He said a conscious being becomes part of the moral community. A non-conscious machine does not. He also said AI systems can simulate morality without having real moral beliefs.

For readers, the practical point is to treat chatbot statements about feelings as generated language, not proof of a mind. Anyone seeking formal guidance should consult official material from the relevant AI provider. The interview shows how AI has become a topic for philosophers as well as engineers.

Sources

  1. ‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI ConsciousnessWIRED

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.