Google Search faces school district backlash over AI
Major US school districts are considering alternatives after Google said schools that disable Gemini AI features will also lose Search. The dispute has drawn criticism from elected officials and raised questions about classroom technology.

Key takeaways
- Google says schools that disable Gemini AI features will also lose Google Search from next year.
- New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are considering other search options.
- Google plans to pilot Guided Learning in Search and update school controls next year.
- Schools rely heavily on Google Classroom, Chromebooks and other Google services.
In this article
What Google plans to change
According to The Verge, citing The New York Times, Google has told schools that a major change is coming. From next year, schools will not be able to switch off Gemini-powered features while keeping Google Search. Gemini is Google's artificial intelligence system.
Chris Phillips, Google's vice president of education, told The New York Times that Search and AI are closely connected. He said schools that disable Google's AI tools will lose Search as well. The Verge reported that the change will affect schools that use Google's education products.
The practical effect is simple. A school that wants Search without AI features may have to leave Google Search. That is why several large districts are now considering alternatives.
Districts consider alternatives
The dispute has already reached some of the largest school systems in the United States. New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are considering alternatives, according to The Verge. The New York Times reported that the districts are looking at other search options.
New York City schools chancellor Kamar H. Samuels said the district would explore other options. His statement said this would happen if Google does not reconsider its position. Chicago's school system has reportedly told Google that it will seek other search solutions. It asked for Search without AI.
The reaction has been political as well. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Senator Bernie Sanders criticised Google's move. They described the company's behaviour as extortion. Mamdani recently announced a policy that prohibits AI use for younger students.
Google's response and new controls
Google has defended its approach. Spokesperson Laura Breen said the company hears concerns from parents and teachers. She said those concerns include students using AI to take shortcuts in learning. Breen said Google shares the goal of helping students learn.
Google said it will begin a Guided Learning pilot in Search this month. The feature is intended to guide students through complex problems. It is meant to offer more support than quick answers.
Google also said it will update school controls next year. The update responds to feedback from educators. Under the planned change, the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be disabled by default. Schools will then decide which services to enable. Google said it is building these experiences with educators.
Why schools are worried

Educators are worried about the effect of AI on students. The Verge noted that some studies have found lower test results among students who use AI. The report also pointed to concerns about mental health. These concerns involve children who form bonds with chatbots early in life. Educators are also wary about critical thinking.
Google is widely used in US classrooms. Many schools rely on Google Classroom, Chromebooks and other Google services. The Verge said leaving Google entirely could be difficult. That makes the current dispute more than a simple product choice.
The issue is about control as well as technology. Schools want to decide which digital tools students use. Google says its AI features are meant to improve Search for classrooms. Several districts are not convinced and are exploring alternatives.
What happens next
The next step is a decision by school leaders. Districts must choose whether to accept Google's AI-integrated Search or look elsewhere. Google says it will give schools more control next year. It says Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be disabled until schools enable them.
For now, the largest districts are keeping their options open. New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are considering other search providers. Google has said it is working with educators and will continue to adjust its products.
The dispute shows how AI features can become tied to core classroom tools. It also shows that schools are reconsidering services they rely on.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



