Tech BusinessTech Policy & Law
Forced arbitration and deepfake lawsuits return to Congress
US lawmakers are pushing new bills that would limit forced arbitration and let victims of intimate deepfakes sue, according to The Verge.

Key takeaways
- A Senate Judiciary panel examined Roblox's use of forced arbitration in child safety lawsuits.
- Roblox faces roughly 180 lawsuits in a combined case over alleged child grooming.
- The Defiance Act would let victims of nonconsensual intimate deepfakes sue creators.
- Lawmakers say ending forced arbitration could expose companies to more public court cases.
In this article
Forced arbitration takes centre stage
Forced arbitration is at the centre of a new push in the US Senate. According to The Verge, a Senate Judiciary panel held a hearing on Tuesday to argue that companies should not use arbitration clauses to block lawsuits over online harm.
The hearing focused on Roblox, a gaming platform popular with children. Lawmakers said the company was relying on arbitration terms agreed to by users who were minors at the time, in some cases below the age of 10.
Senator Josh Hawley, who chairs the panel, said public court cases are a stronger way to force companies to change. He introduced a bill with Senator Dick Durbin that would make arbitration agreements unenforceable in disputes involving alleged sexual exploitation of children or child cyber injury. The bill says such injury could include damage to reputation, mental suffering or death.
The push comes with only a few weeks left in 2026. Hawley said juries are hard to corrupt and can be a powerful check on corporate behaviour.
Roblox cases and the arbitration fight
Roblox is facing roughly 180 lawsuits in a combined case. The cases claim the company failed to protect children from grooming on its platform.
Roblox has asked courts to apply its arbitration clause in those lawsuits. If arbitration is used, the public would not see legal discovery, the evidence-gathering stage that has produced material in recent cases against Meta.
Roblox denies that it is trying to avoid accountability. Nicky Jackson Colaço, the company's global head of public policy, said safety has been central since launch. She said Roblox requires age checks for chat, places users under 16 in accounts based on age with protective defaults, and stops images and video from being shared in chat.
She also said a legal stance on arbitration does not measure safety. The hearing, she said, did not advance safety.
Deepfake victims seek a court route

A separate effort on Capitol Hill focused on nonconsensual intimate deepfakes. These are fake images or videos made with AI that show a person in sexual or intimate scenes without consent.
Representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Laurel Lee brought Paris Hilton to Congress to support the Defiance Act. The bill would let victims of such deepfakes sue their creators for damages.
Hilton said the number of people victimised by sexually explicit deepfakes is over 50 million. She said strangers have made more than 100,000 explicit images and videos of her using AI. She said she would keep coming back until the bill becomes law and that she keeps promises to survivors.
Elliston Berry said a classmate used a social media post to create an explicit deepfake picture of her and her friends when she was 14. She said the image was spread around her school.
Why the legal fight matters
Lawsuits have become a major route for survivors of online harm to seek change. Congress has not passed many high-profile bills on child safety, on privacy and on consumer protection.
It has started to tackle deepfakes with the Take It Down Act. At the same time, state attorneys general and private plaintiffs have secured settlements and court wins despite Section 230, a law that gives online platforms broad protection from many claims over user content.
If the Defiance Act or the arbitration bills become law, tech companies and people accused of online harm could face a new wave of lawsuits. Richard Blumenthal, Katie Britt and Cory Booker introduced a similar arbitration bill. Their version also covers data privacy violations.
Myriam Gilles, a law professor at Northwestern University, said she had testified many times about forced arbitration but had not expected to discuss its use against nine-year-olds. She said passing either proposal would have a major effect. In her view, companies can change fast after a public court case.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



