Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

AppleApple Services

Epic Apple documents dispute seeks daily fines

Epic Games asks a court to impose daily fines on Apple, saying the company is withholding more than 122,000 documents in the App Store commission case.

Illustration of Apple logo and legal documents beside a court gavel

Key takeaways

  • Epic says Apple is withholding more than 122,000 documents in the App Store dispute.
  • Epic wants Apple to produce matching files by 2 December 2026, except those protected by legal privilege.
  • Epic asks for daily fines if Apple misses the deadline.
  • A magistrate judge will handle the evidence dispute after a new order.
In this article
  1. What Epic alleges
  2. The documents at issue
  3. Proposed remedy and fines
  4. Hearing status and background
  5. Why it matters

What Epic alleges

According to 9to5 Mac, Epic Games has filed a new court document. It accuses Apple of holding back more than 122,000 files. The files relate to proposed App Store commissions. The Epic Apple documents dispute is part of a long-running legal fight. It concerns Apple's App Store rules. Epic says the missing material may show how Apple set the proposed fees.

The filing says Apple told the court it had completed production. It says Apple produced files from certain key employees. Epic disputes that claim. It says the production lacks a substantive email about the rates Apple proposed. Epic argues Apple is unlikely to correct the problem without a court order.

The documents at issue

Epic says the withheld files come from agreed searches. Both sides agreed to the search terms. The searches covered four people Apple says decided the proposed fee. They are Tim Cook, Eddy Cue, Carson Oliver and Kevan Parekh. Parekh is Apple's new CFO. The searches also covered three other key individuals. They are Nate Barton, Alex Roman and Phil Schiller.

According to the filing, Apple produced 632 documents from custodial files. These were returned by the search terms and include document families. Apple is withholding more than 122,000 documents. It says they are not responsive. Epic says the withheld total is well above 99% of the search results for those files. It says many withheld files contain terms tied to the case. Examples include contempt and injunction.

Epic also says Apple has changed its approach. During the contempt proceeding, Epic says Apple used privilege claims. It says Apple used them to avoid evidence duties. In the current dispute, Epic says Apple relies on relevance claims.

Proposed remedy and fines

Epic wants the court to order Apple to produce more files. The files must match the agreed search terms. Epic says the order should cover all files not protected by legal privilege. Under this proposal, Apple could still review files for legal privilege. Epic would then decide which files are relevant.

Epic says existing confidentiality protections would limit use of the material. It says the material could not be used for unrelated purposes. Epic asks for production by 2 December 2026. That is one week after Apple's deadline to complete most of its production. Epic says the order should apply regardless of Apple's relevance or responsiveness assessment.

Epic also asks for a daily monetary sanction. It would apply for each day Apple fails to comply after 2 December 2026. The filing does not propose a specific dollar amount. Epic says a court order is needed because Apple may not correct the problem alone.

Hearing status and background

Illustration: law, Apple logo, App Store logo, shopping and the labels App Store, Apple, Epic Games

The dispute is rooted in the 2020 lawsuit brought by Epic Games against Apple. In 2021, Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers ruled for Epic on one point. Apple would have to allow developers to point users to payment options beyond the App Store. That ruling is part of the wider battle over App Store rules and commissions.

A hearing on Epic's motion was initially set for 24 November. It was to take place before Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers. According to 9to5 Mac, a new order was filed on 17 November 2026. It refers the evidence dispute to a magistrate judge. The order is not public yet. It also includes a notice ending deadlines and hearings.

Why it matters

The request matters because it could change how evidence is handled. Epic wants to review files itself after Apple checks for legal privilege. It says this would avoid further delays. It also says this would not burden Apple.

The dispute shows the case has moved from App Store rules to document questions. The proposed daily sanction would apply if Apple fails to meet the production deadline. The magistrate judge will now handle the evidence dispute.

Sources

  1. Epic accuses Apple of withholding 122,000 documents, seeks daily fines9to5 Mac

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.