Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

AppleApple Services

Apple just works approach criticised over missing controls

A 9to5Mac opinion piece argues that Apple's preference for technology that simply works can leave users unable to start a sync or see whether a task has finished. The author wants manual triggers and progress indicators across AirPods, iCloud and Photos.

Illustration of an iPhone and a Mac showing stalled iCloud sync and AirPods firmware update icons

Key takeaways

  • 9to5Mac's Ben Lovejoy argues that Apple's just works approach can take away control that some users want.
  • AirPods firmware cannot be installed on demand; Apple's support document lists the conditions and a wait of at least 30 minutes.
  • iCloud document sync and Photos offer no manual trigger or progress display, the piece says.
  • The author wants manual start options, progress indicators and completion confirmation across Apple's ecosystem.
In this article
  1. A slogan that started with customers
  2. AirPods updates arrive on Apple's timetable
  3. No manual start for iCloud or Photos
  4. A Sync Now button that reports success
  5. Commentary rather than a product change

A slogan that started with customers

The phrase is closely associated with Apple, but according to Ben Lovejoy's opinion piece for 9to5Mac, it began with customers rather than the company. He cites a 1996 Apple brochure called Why do people prefer Macintosh?, which gathered testimonials from owners, several of whom used the wording. Reviewers adopted it afterwards, and Lovejoy says the earliest use by Steve Jobs he could trace was in 1999, when FireWire arrived on the Mac with the PowerMac G3.

Jobs described the appeal of peripherals that can be connected while the machine is running, with drivers loaded as needed and no terminators or switches to set. He closed that description with the line It just works. Lovejoy writes that he shares the goal: people should be able to finish their tasks without thinking about the machinery underneath.

AirPods updates arrive on Apple's timetable

Illustration: headphones, Apple logo, update, camera and the labels 9to5mac, AirPods, Apple

Lovejoy's main objection is that the approach sometimes removes choices that experienced users value. His first example is AirPods firmware. A September release added a custom equaliser, a fairly basic version of a feature that had been requested for a long time, yet owners could not install it on demand.

Apple's support document, as the piece describes it, sets out the conditions for an update: the buds connected by Bluetooth to an iPhone, iPad or Mac, the case plugged into power, the AirPods inside with the lid shut, and the whole set kept within range. It then advises waiting at least 30 minutes before checking the version again. In practice, Lovejoy notes, the only way to learn whether the update has landed is to look repeatedly.

No manual start for iCloud or Photos

iCloud document sync draws similar criticism. The piece says there is no manual start and no indication of progress, so a sync that takes seconds in the best case and hours in the worst gives the user nothing to watch or act on.

Photos and video add another layer of uncertainty. A clip recorded on an iPhone may be moved to iCloud and need downloading before it can be edited, while footage shot months earlier can still be stored on the handset. Optimisation can be switched off entirely, but Lovejoy argues that leaves no middle ground and calls for a setting that keeps recent captures, such as everything from the past two weeks, on the device.

A Sync Now button that reports success

On the Mac, the Sync Now button in Photos can report that the library is current while a video is still absent, according to the piece. Dragging a clip from Photos into a folder does begin a transfer, but the interface gives no sign of it: no dimmed icon and no progress bar, just a file that appears later.

Lovejoy's proposal is not to abandon simplicity but to add options alongside it. He wants a standard way to start processes that otherwise run on Apple's timetable, together with progress indicators and confirmation when a job is done. He accepts that many less technical users will be content to wait, and frames the request as an improvement for the whole ecosystem.

Commentary rather than a product change

The article is opinion rather than a report of new software or a shift in policy, and it does not say that Apple has responded. Its examples come from the author's own use of Apple devices, and the recommendations are his own.

Readers who share the frustration are invited to add examples in the comments, which is where the piece ends. The only concrete guidance in the material is Apple's published routine for AirPods updates and the option to switch off photo optimisation.

Sources

  1. Apple’s ‘just works’ approach is great, but goes a little too far9to5 Mac

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.