Skip to content
Theme
OnDevice Tools

GadgetsSmart Home

Apple HomeView audio tested: good sound, but third-party apps lag behind

The Verge has published a follow-up to its HomeView review, examining the smart display's speaker performance, stereo pairing limits and third-party music app support in detail.

Illustration of an Apple HomeView smart display on a kitchen counter playing music

Key takeaways

  • The tabletop HomeView sounds roughly on par with the HomePod Mini 2, with better bass and volume but less clarity and room-filling sound.
  • Two HomeViews cannot be paired for stereo, and the wall-mounted model has thin sound with almost no bass.
  • Audio and video handoff work broadly, including video, though Netflix and Prime Video transfer audio only.
  • Third-party apps run through Apple's CarPlay platform, which brings no search, profile requirements and slower performance.
In this article
  1. How the HomeView sounds
  2. Wall mounting comes at a cost
  3. No stereo pairing, but AirPlay and handoff work well
  4. Default speakers and third-party app limits
  5. Why CarPlay is the bottleneck

How the HomeView sounds

Apple's first smart display has been put through a second round of audio testing. According to The Verge, the HomeView sits close to the HomePod Mini in both size and sound quality, though it does not match larger speakers such as the full-size HomePod or the Sonos One.

Compared with the HomePod Mini 2, the publication found the tabletop HomeView offers stronger bass and slightly higher volume, but the Mini sounds clearer and fills a room better, partly because it projects sound in all directions. The HomeView does support Spatial Audio with Dolby Atmos, which the Mini 2 lacks.

The hardware explains the trade-offs. The display sits over the base and partly covers the woofer, which affects the sound. Apple has added an accelerometer so the HomeView can adjust its equaliser in real time as the screen is tilted.

Wall mounting comes at a cost

The wall-mounted version of the HomeView is a different story. It has only two drivers, with computational audio that Apple says is tuned specifically for on-wall placement.

The Verge reports that this version sounds noticeably thinner than the tabletop model, with almost no bass. The publication does not recommend it for sound quality alone, but notes it works well for speaking to visitors through a video doorbell.

No stereo pairing, but AirPlay and handoff work well

Two HomeViews cannot be paired for stereo sound, and the display cannot be paired with a HomePod or HomePod Mini either. It can, however, be grouped with any AirPlay speakers so they all play at once. The Verge suggests that anyone with 300 dollars to spend on a smart speaker setup would be better served by two paired Minis, since the HomeView's main advantage is its screen rather than its sound.

Where the display does shine is as a music controller. The touchscreen works like a jukebox, making it simple to skip tracks, pick new music and browse podcasts or audiobooks without relying on Siri or a phone.

AirPlay works as it does on any AirPlay speaker, and audio handoff behaves the same as on a HomePod: tapping a phone against the HomeView transfers whatever is playing to the speaker and screen, and it works in reverse too. YouTube and YouTube TV videos also handed off despite having no HomeView apps, while Netflix and Amazon Prime Video transferred audio only, although both played video in the Safari browser.

One caution from the testing: handoff is very sensitive. Holding a phone within a few inches of the display can trigger a transfer, just as with HomePods.

Default speakers and third-party app limits

Illustration: speaker, Apple logo, music, computer and the labels Airplay, Apple, CarPlay

The HomeView does not allow a default speaker or speaker group to be set. Audio can still be sent to any AirPlay speaker or group, and The Verge found this worked smoothly on HomePods, Sonos speakers and a Samsung TV. For Apple's own apps, the display remembers the last speakers used and plays through them again, or offers that option if some time has passed.

Third-party apps are less consistent. If content is chosen on the HomeView screen, the last-used speakers are remembered, but Siri voice control always defaults to the HomeView's own speaker unless a room name is added to the command. With Apple Music no extra words are needed.

The Verge calls third-party app support its biggest complaint about the HomeView as a smart speaker. Non-native apps such as Spotify and Audible only appear when the user's phone is connected via their profile, so only that person can use them.

Why CarPlay is the bottleneck

The root of the limitations is Apple's approach to app support. Rather than building a dedicated platform for the HomeView, Apple reuses its CarPlay system, the software designed for car dashboards. Any audio or video app that already supports CarPlay works on the display, with no support for other kinds of CarPlay apps.

This makes life easier for developers but creates real drawbacks for users. The Verge notes there is no search function in these apps, a design choice made because drivers are not supposed to type, which is less helpful in a kitchen. A user profile is required, the phone must be on the same Wi-Fi network, and performance is slower and less consistent than in the native apps.

The publication tried Pocket Casts, Amazon Music, YouTube Music, Spotify and Audible, and all appeared in the app drawer. The overall picture from the testing is that the HomeView is a capable smart speaker with a genuinely useful screen, but anyone who relies heavily on third-party music services should expect a second-class experience.

Sources

  1. Your questions about Apple HomeView’s audio, answeredThe Verge

Tags

Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.