Apple faces French court over planned obsolescence
France is taking Apple to court over planned obsolescence, a case that could shape how repairs are limited.

Key takeaways
- France plans to prosecute Apple over repair restrictions.
- HOP says Apple uses serial numbers to block unaugmented repairs.
- France made repair limits illegal in 2021, according to HOP.
- A hearing is set for 25 February 2027.
In this article
What changed

France is taking Apple to court over planned obsolescence, according to Apple Insider. A French pressure group said Apple will be prosecuted before the Paris Criminal Court. The public prosecutor of Paris decided to sue the company, and a hearing is set for 25 February 2027.
The case followed complaints from the group. HOP announced that Apple would face prosecution. The dispute is about repair rules and device longevity.
The group said the complaint concerns iPhones and repair roadblocks. HOP filed its complaint in December 2022, and an investigation began in May 2023.
Repair limits
The pressure group, Halte l'Obsolescence Programme, or HOP, said the problem is that Apple uses hardware and software methods to stop repairs. HOP said Apple uses serial numbers on components and peripherals. The group said these can detect a replaced part and lead to faults.
Apple uses serialised parts to restrict repairs. It limits them to authorised repair centres. It also stops authorised repair shops from using parts that are not certified.
The group said blocking repairs is illegal in France after a 2021 amendment to the Consumer Code. Apple's self-service repair programme went on sale in France on 6 December 2022, a day before HOP filed its complaint.
HOP said the aim is that parts from Apple's self-service repair programme match the intended device. The group has disputed that aim.
Who is affected
The case centres on French consumers and repair businesses, according to the pressure group. HOP is the French association bringing the complaint. Apple France has not commented publicly.
The public prosecutor of Paris is leading the case. The hearing will take place at the Paris Criminal Court.
What it means
The hearing will take place at the Paris Criminal Court. The case could decide whether repair limits are lawful. It could also affect how Apple restricts repairs in France.
The group said it no longer wants both an economic and environmental cost linked to obsolescence. The case is at an early stage before the hearing.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



