Bill C-22: Meta warns it may pull encrypted services from Canada
Meta has told Canadian senators that Bill C-22 could force it to withdraw encrypted services, as it warns the proposed law would undermine secure communications.

Key takeaways
- Meta told Canadian senators it may withdraw encrypted services if Bill C-22 passes.
- The bill would allow confidential orders requiring providers to build access for law enforcement.
- Google, Apple and Signal have opposed the bill, while Windscribe pledged to keep its no-logs policy.
- The Senate committee is the bill's final legislative hurdle before potential passage.
In this article
Meta warns over Bill C-22
According to TechRadar, Meta has warned Canadian senators that it may pull encrypted services from Canada if Bill C-22 becomes law. The company made the comments during a Senate committee hearing on Monday, alongside representatives from Signal and Tailscale.
The session came as the government of Prime Minister Mark Carney is under pressure from digital rights groups and technology firms. Meta said the proposed rules would make it technically impossible to keep offering secure encrypted communications.
Robyn Greene, Meta's privacy and public policy director, told senators that Ottawa would be enforcing a law that cannot be met while still providing secure encrypted services to Canadians. Rachel Curran, who leads public policy for Meta in Canada, said the company would need to examine every option. She confirmed that withdrawal was an option Meta would need to consider.
Curran had earlier told Bloomberg that Meta would not compromise system security. She called any weakening of system security a red line. She also warned that the bill could turn private platforms into part of state surveillance.
What Bill C-22 would change
Bill C-22, also called the Lawful Access Act, was approved by Canadian legislators in June. It is now before the Senate. The main concern for technology firms is Part 2 of the bill.
That part would allow confidential ministerial orders. These orders could require providers of electronic services to create methods for police and intelligence agencies to access communications when requested. The bill would also allow rules that require companies to retain sensitive customer metadata for up to six months. Metadata is information about communications, such as connection records and IP addresses, which identify devices on a network.
Canadian authorities have introduced amendments that bar orders requiring a systemic vulnerability. However, industry groups say the wording is unclear and could leave key protections exposed.
Why encrypted services are at risk

Encrypted messaging apps and VPNs, which help protect web traffic, depend on strong encryption to keep user data private. End-to-end encryption means that only the sender and the intended receiver can read a message. If a provider is forced to build an access point for authorities, critics say that same access point could be abused.
Cryptographers and privacy advocates argue that giving police access to private chats would weaken security for all users. They warn that if engineers create an interception mechanism for domestic authorities, cybercriminals and foreign spies may find and exploit it.
The coalition against the bill is broad. Google has warned that the bill threatens end-to-end encryption. Apple has warned that the powers risk customer security. Signal has said it may leave Canada. Canadian provider Windscribe has pledged to keep its no-logs policy, which limits the data it keeps, unchanged. Advocacy groups are pressing for changes and have asked European authorities to intervene.
What it means for Canadians
The Senate committee is the bill's final legislative hurdle before it could become law. Technology companies appear to be hoping that the threat of service withdrawals will persuade lawmakers to amend the text.
Meta has not said exactly which services it might withdraw. It did not exclude withdrawing services such as WhatsApp. That creates uncertainty for Canadians who rely on encrypted messaging for private conversations.
The dispute also highlights a wider tension between lawful access, meaning state access to communications, and strong encryption. Governments want tools to help police and intelligence agencies. Technology firms and privacy advocates say those tools can create risks for all users. For now, the bill remains under review, and Meta's warning adds pressure on Canadian senators to consider changes.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



