Apple disputes Epic Games claim it withheld 122,000 documents
Apple told a court that at least 95% of the files Epic's searches flagged had no link to link-out fees, and that producing them all by 2 December is not possible.

Key takeaways
- Apple told a court it should only hand over documents relevant to Epic's requests, not every file matching the agreed search terms.
- Apple says at least 95% of the flagged files matched generic terms and never mentioned link-out.
- Apple says the searches also caught tax, medical and password files, plus details of unannounced products.
- Apple calls Epic's proposed 2 December deadline unworkable and offers a Special Master review of a sample instead.
In this article
What Apple told the court

The Apple Epic Games documents dispute has taken a new turn, with Apple telling a court that it should not have to hand over every file matching the search terms both sides agreed on. 9to5 Mac reported on 19 November 2026 that Apple had filed its answer to an Epic motion made the previous Friday.
Epic says Apple is improperly holding back more than 122,000 files that match those terms. The figure comes from the records of seven employees treated as the initial custodians, meaning the first group of staff whose files were searched.
Apple says it agreed to Epic's proposed search terms and to cover all employees, and has been producing material it judged responsive to the requests. Its central argument is that the law requires a party to hand over relevant documents, not everything a search string happens to return. This all sits within discovery, the stage before trial when each side must share material the other has asked for.
Why the searches pulled in unrelated files
Apple's filing argues that Epic's terms were overbroad rather than tailored to the case, which concerns proposed App Store commissions and link-out fees. A wildcard search uses an asterisk to match any word that starts with the same letters. Apple says Epic's use of fee* in searches about litigation and its link-out work therefore caught feel, feed, feedback, feet and feeble, none of which contain the word fee.
According to Apple, at least 95% of the initial custodian document population matched generic terms of that kind and made no mention of link-out or its variations. Apple says link-out is central to the discovery, so those hits are largely beside the point. The company does not deny that the searches returned the files Epic counted. It disputes what the count means.
Apple also cites case law for the position that a court will not order production simply because a document contains a search term. It argues that guesswork based on hit totals, where the producing side can explain a low relevance rate, does not justify the remedy Epic is seeking.
Sensitive material caught by the broad terms
The wide terms also swept up material Apple describes as highly sensitive. In its filing the company lists staff tax and financial records, medical records, files about products it has not announced, documents containing passwords, investor-relations material and legal communications that are privileged or otherwise protected.
Apple says the sweeping terms did two things at once. They increased the total volume of files, and they captured records that should not be shared outside the company. Privilege covers legal advice and related communications that a court will normally keep out of evidence.
Apple says the 2 December deadline is unworkable
That review is the basis of Apple's objection to timing. The company says checking so many files for privileged or sensitive content, and blacking out protected passages, is extensive work. It argues this makes Epic's proposed deadline of 2 December impossible to meet.
Apple asks the court to reject Epic's motion outright. If the judge decides that some intervention is warranted, Apple offers a compromise. A random sample of the files it considers non-responsive, large enough to be statistically significant, would go to a Special Master for independent examination. A Special Master is an expert a court appoints to look at evidence. Under Apple's plan that expert, rather than Epic, would see the sample.
What Epic wants, and what comes next
Epic's own request is wider. It has asked the court to order Apple to produce all matching documents that are not privileged, whatever Apple's own view of their relevance.
Nothing in the report suggests the court has ruled yet. The next step is a decision on Epic's motion, which will shape how much material Apple must hand over in the continuing argument over its proposed App Store commissions and link-out fees.
Sources
Spotted a mistake? See our corrections policy. Read how News by OnDevice works in our editorial policy.



